House, "The Abbey", including interiors

Item details

Name of item: House, "The Abbey", including interiors
Type of item: Built
Group/Collection: Residential buildings (private)
Category: Villa
Primary address: 272 Johnston Street, Annandale, NSW 2038
County: Cumberland
Local govt. area: Inner West
All addresses
Street AddressSuburb/townLGAParishCountyType
272 Johnston StreetAnnandaleInner West CumberlandPrimary Address

Statement of significance:

The Abbey, No. 272 Johnston Street, Annandale has local historic, aesthetic, technological and social significance as one of the finest examples of the Gothic Revival style in Australia. Built in 1881, the building is associated with John Young, master builder and promoter of Annandale.

The main part of the house retains its original form, height and character as presents to Johnston Street, characterised by its gothic details such as traceried windows, elaborate mouldings, carved stone crests, and gargoyles guarding the tower. The Abbey is rich in Masonic symbols and is believed to have once served as a masonic lodge.

The building is the most prominent of a notable group of houses and has landmark qualities. With the associated group known as “The Witches’ Houses” it is an outstanding and unique collection of late Victorian, high quality dwellings that are considered to be worthy of State Heritage Significance.

The building is a representative example of a semi-detached dwelling constructed in the late Victorian style in the c. 1890s-1910s.

Note: This inventory sheet is not intended to be a definitive study of the heritage item, therefore information may not be accurate and complete. The information should be regarded as a general guide. Further research is always recommended as part of the preparation of development proposals for heritage items.
Date significance updated: 13 Feb 12
Note: The State Heritage Inventory provides information about heritage items listed by local and State government agencies. The State Heritage Inventory is continually being updated by local and State agencies as new information becomes available. Read the Department of Premier and Cabinet copyright and disclaimer.

Description

Builder/Maker: John Young
Construction years: 1881-1882
Physical description: The Abbey is one of a group of prominent houses in Johnston Street, Annandale, known as “The Witches’ Houses”.

The Abbey is a large complex sandstone structure built in the Victorian Rustic Gothic style with elements of a romantic Scottish Baronial manor. Its design has been attributed to William Wardell, who designed St Mary's Cathedral in Sydney and Young was the builder. It has three sections on different levels of the sloping site, the main house to the east overlooking Johnston Street; the stables and so-called ballroom to the west, facing the rear lane and the middle section consisting of a kitchen and what were called the servant’s quarters.

The exterior of the building is a robust asymmetrical composition of rock-faced sandstone walling, steeply pitched slate gable ended roofs, extensive arcading, crenulated parapets, and strong vertical features such as chimneys. It includes many gothic details such as arches, gables, traceried windows, elaborate mouldings, quatrefoils, turrets, a cloister and carved stone crests and gargoyles guarding the tower. The tower with copper cladding is a dominant feature of the building and is a landmark.

The interior is elaborately detailed with Arts and Craft decoration, with a Pugin theme and a variety of tiles from Minton's by Moyr-Smith as well as massive built-in furniture and frescos. Lyon and Cottier provided interior decorations such as stencils, furniture and glass. Parnell Wressel Johnson designed much of the artwork for Lyon and Cottier.

The garden contains dense foliage and surrounds the house. A high stone wall surrounds the street corner and continues to front the group of houses up to No. 260. It contains a gateway with timber door and a gothic stone archway with the date 1881 carved on it.

On the rear lane there is a two-three storey building originally used as stables and later converted to flats. The stonework is completely covered in vines. The building has a clear story at the top.
Physical condition and/or
Archaeological potential:
Very good. Some of the stonework appears weathered. There are vines growing on the stonework at ground floor level.
The rear building known as the 'stables' has vines growing on the walls..
Date condition updated:17 Nov 11
Modifications and dates: 1961- External stairway
1963 - Alterations
Feb 1965 - Erection open verandah
Sept 1965 - Dining room & study to caretakers flat
1967 - Alterations to kitchen
1968 - Swimming pool
2011 - New landscaping (D/2010/597)
2011 - Reconstruction of northern boundary wall (D/2011/159)
2011 - Alterations to the rear wing, tower and stables building (D/2011/317)
2013 - Swimming pool with associated landscaping works (D/2013/144)
Current use: Residential
Former use: Residential

History

Historical notes: Most of the suburb of Annandale, 290 acres, was granted in 1799 to Major, later Colonel, George Johnston, a marine officer of the First Fleet who commanded the military forces of the colony and named the area after his home town in Scotland. Johnston constructed Annandale House on his grant which was also associated with the introduction of brick-making in the colony, the first batch of bricks being manufactured on the banks of White’s Creek. The house was located on the southern side of the main road, (Parramatta Road) nearly opposite Johnston Street. It was largely constructed of local cedar in the Georgian style. The family occupied the house from 1800 and despite development closing in on all sides the Annandale Estate remained intact into the 1870s. Annandale House was demolished c.1912.

Johnston was succeeded by his son, Captain Robert Johnston, who had been a naval commander. He leased portions of the estate to industry and oversaw the first subdivision of the estate, known as North Annandale Estate in 1874 and 1875. However sales of the large allotments did not proceed well. A subsequent subdivision in 1876, comprising the land bounded by Parramatta Road, Johnston Street, Collins and Nelson Streets was transferred to Robert’s son, George Johnston, who inturn sold the 75 lots to John Young. Young subsequently purchased the remaining land from Johnston in 1877. John Young, prominent building contractor in the late 19th century and Mayor of Leichhardt (1879-80 and 1884-86), in turn resold the 280 acre estate to the Sydney Freehold Land, Building and Investment Company Ltd which he formed in 1878 and which proceeded to subdivide and sell smaller allotments over a period of over 30 years.

Architect and Surveyor Ferdinand Reuss won the competition organised by the Company for the best design and subdivision layout for Annandale. He created the 100ft wide boulevard along the main ridge, Johnston Street, which was intended to be the finest street in the Colony and encouraged the symmetrical street grid pattern. Annandale Street was also a wide 80 ft street whilst Trafalgar, Nelson and Young Street were designed with 66ft width. The four cross streets, Collins, Booth, Piper and Rose Streets were also designed with the 66ft width.

John Young was the main purchaser of land in the Annandale area and one of the biggest building contractors as well as a prominent citizen. He became a dominant personality in the development of Annandale as a suburb. He decided on the street pattern, including the very wide Johnston Street, intended to be the finest street in the area. John Young lived at Kentville, a house built on a three-hectare garden setting that stretched from the Abbey to the bay. The home was surrounded by landscaped areas including the earliest bowling greens in Australia. Young died in 1907 and the whole site was cleared and subdivided into about 90 allotments.

The Abbey’s site was not owned by Young until January 1882 when he bought it off his neighbour, C.H. Blackmann, who built Oybin in 1880. A small building was originally built on the site which was retained to become the kitchen and the servants quarters and was incorporated into the new house.
It is believed that Young built the Abbey in 1881-1882 for a few reasons. One is that he wanted to induce his wife to return to Australia and that building a grand house would do this, but she never returned. Another reason is that Young was a freemason and the Abbey may have been built as a lodge. The Abbey is rich in Masonic symbols, having a layout similar to a typical lodge. Overlooking Kentville, it was ideally placed as a retreat for Young and his friends, almost as an exclusive and private club.
There is no evidence that Young lived at the Abbey. At the turn of the century the Abbey was used as a superior boarding house, while the mezzanine above the stables was used to accommodate one of Sydney’s many private schools. In 1901 Maurice Aron and Parnell Johnson lived there.

After John Young died the property was passed to his son Frederick and son-in-law Sylvanus Patridge Reynolds, trustees for the Estate. They arranged a series of tenancies, subdividing some of the spaces and adding sanitary facilities in the process. In 1916 the tenants were Sarah O’Brien and her married daughters and offspring. From 1924-1931 Ernest Warren and his wife lived there until the death of his wife in a tragic car accident. Warren then installed two flats in the ‘ballroom’ and had the rest of the building converted into flats and flatettes. Lancelot Davis purchased the property in 1959 for his son Dr Geoffrey Davis who moved into one unit in the rear of the west wing and slowly occupied the house as tenants moved out or passed away. Mr Davis began restoration in 1983, teaching and working with his son William from age 11. In September 2006 work was put on hold. The property has since been sold, in 2009, and the owners plan to continue with the restoration.

Historic themes

Australian theme (abbrev)New South Wales themeLocal theme
4. Settlement-Building settlements, towns and cities Accommodation-Activities associated with the provision of accommodation, and particular types of accommodation – does not include architectural styles – use the theme of Creative Endeavour for such activities. Growth of Annandale-

Assessment of significance

SHR Criteria a)
[Historical significance]
The building has high local historic significance as an excellent example of a unique building built in 1881, associated with a group of prominent houses in Johnston Street, Annandale, known as “The Witches’ Houses”.
SHR Criteria b)
[Associative significance]
The building is associated with John Young who was a dominant personality in the development of Annandale as well as a prominent builder and citizen.
SHR Criteria c)
[Aesthetic significance]
The Abbey has aesthetic significance as a large complex sandstone structure built in the Victorian Rustic Gothic style with many gothic details such as traceried windows, elaborate mouldings, carved stone crests and gargoyles guarding the tower. The tower is a dominant feature of the building and is a landmark.
SHR Criteria d)
[Social significance]
The Abbey is possibly associated with being a Masonic lodge as it contains masonic symbols and layout of the building.
SHR Criteria e)
[Research potential]
John Young was one of the pioneers of concrete in Australia and the Abbey has a thick concrete floor reinforced with iron railway lines, canterlevering out half a metre beyond the basement walls which support it as well as supporting the north wall of the banqueting room.
SHR Criteria f)
[Rarity]
The Abbey is rare in Annandale as a prominent and unique building built in the Victorian Rustic Gothic style and is associated with the group known as “The Witches’ Houses”. Together the group is an outstanding and unique collection of late Victorian, high quality dwellings.
SHR Criteria g)
[Representativeness]
The Abbey is a representative example of a Victorian Rustic Gothic villa belonging to a distinct group of houses in Johnston Street, Annandale.
Integrity/Intactness: High
Assessment criteria: Items are assessed against the PDF State Heritage Register (SHR) Criteria to determine the level of significance. Refer to the Listings below for the level of statutory protection.

Recommended management:

It is recommended that: - the building be nominated for the State Heritage Listing. - elements that contribute to the architectural character of the building as presents to Johnston and Weynton Streets including the rear stable building should be retained, - any further works should be in accordance with a Conservation Management Plan/Strategy. - the existing curtilage of the building and setbacks should be retained. - the vines growing on the Weynton Street stone boundary wall and rear stone building should be removed.

Listings

Heritage ListingListing TitleListing NumberGazette DateGazette NumberGazette Page
Local Environmental PlanLeichhardt Local Environmental Plan 2013I6523 Dec 13   

Study details

TitleYearNumberAuthorInspected byGuidelines used
Leichhardt Municipality Heritage Study1990 McDonald McPhee Pty Ltd (Craig Burton, Wendy Thorp)  Yes

References, internet links & images

TypeAuthorYearTitleInternet Links
WrittenAnnandale Group1973An Introduction to Annandale
WrittenMax Solling and Peter reynolds1997Leichhardt on the Margins of the City
WrittenRobert Irving, John Kinstler, Max Dupain1982Fine Houses Of Sydney

Note: internet links may be to web pages, documents or images.

rez rez rez rez rez rez
rez
(Click on thumbnail for full size image and image details)

Data source

The information for this entry comes from the following source:
Name: Local Government
Database number: 1940067


Every effort has been made to ensure that information contained in the State Heritage Inventory is correct. If you find any errors or omissions please send your comments to the Database Manager.

All information and pictures on this page are the copyright of Heritage NSW or respective copyright owners.