| |
SHR Criteria a) [Historical significance] | The area was occupied by the Cadigal, Wangal, Borogegal and Gameragal clans. The Precinct retains some of these clans place names and is illustrated by several early colonial artists and cartographers in its precolonial landform and vegetation, sometimes with Aboriginal people in view, making it one of the oldest places on the continent so depicted. There is evidence that there were Aboriginal people using Millers Point until at least the 1840s.• Millers Point & Walsh Bay Special Area is of state significance for its ability to demonstrate, in its physical forms and associated documentary evidence, over 200 years of European settlement – making it one of a few sites in Australia to display the oldest such continuum of evidence on one site since the beginning of British colonisation in 1788.
The elevated height, abundance of sandstone and long shoreline of Aboriginal middens along Darling Harbour was important in encouraging industrial, commercial and defence activities in the area.
British settlement in the area began with the first colonial fortifications, then the development of wharves and dock facilities and their associated housing. The outbreak of the Plague in 1900 and the consequent mass-resumption of the area and its large-scale rebuilding during the early 20th century was a significant period. It was followed with the development of waterside trade, underlain by a continuing separation from the rest of the City of Sydney by topography and social differentiations to the present day. All of these historical phases remain evident in the area.
The area is of state and national significance due to its unique characteristics, composition, architectural diversity and its continuity of nineteenth and twentieth century residential and maritime elements. It is a living community with clearly discernible links to the maritime industries that formed the village’s core from the early part of the nineteenth century, and one that has long-term memories of the precinct’s fabric and relevance. Its architecture is representative of each decade from the 1820s to the 1930s, with many structures of excellent aesthetic, technical or rare value.
The street pattern of this suburb demonstrates both early nineteenth century transport routes, early haphazard development and replanning and urban design in the latter part of the nineteenth century. Further, it provides evidence of early twentieth century government policy, with large portions of the landscape re-shaped in response to the bubonic plague health crisis and through resumption by the State government. It features, virtually intact, residential areas, port and stevedoring works created by the Sydney Harbour Trust, 1900 1930, in response to the Sydney plague and the requirements of maritime trade at that time
Millers Point contains dwellings, shops, businesses, warehouses,, churches, schools, institutions and related maritime structures that remain closely affiliated to the community today in a meaningful fashion. The area contains both private and government controlled components that merge seamlessly into a cohesive whole.
An important feature of the area is the circular stone excavation for the Cahill Expressway that separated the school grounds from observatory hill and from the National Trust Centre (former school buildings) as it marks a phase of development of the city where the whole of the Millers Point area was at considerable risk of loss through new planning policies and development.
The National Trust Centre (and associated buildings) are significant as part of the first 'model school' of the Board of Education, established in Sydney during the mid 1850s and also as a remnant of the first military hospital. The buildings have had a lengthy association with a variety of historically important persons and organisations and are significant as a design of the colony's first Schools Architect, Henry Robertson. The buildings are a remnant of the first Military Hospital. They have historic significance at a State level.
The Observatory's dominant location beside and above the port town, and later, city of Sydney, made it the site for a range of changing uses. All of these were important to, and reflected changes in the development of the colony.
Meets this criteria at a local, state and national level. |
SHR Criteria b) [Associative significance] | Millers Point is of State significance for its many associations with many women and men significant in the history of NSW.
Indigenous
Cadigal people of the area; Colbee, a Cadigal ‘leading man’ in the 1790s;
Non Indigenous
Jack ‘the miller’ Leighton, wind mill owner;
William Walker, merchant;
Henry Moore, merchant;
Robert Towns, merchant;
Sisters of St Joseph, Catholic nuns at St Brigit’s;
the ‘Millers Point Push’, gangsters of the Point;
Ted Brady, wharf labourer, ALP and Communist Part stalwart;
Arthur Payne, first sufferer of the Plague in 1900;
William Morris Hughes, union leader and later prime minister;
Waterside Workers Federation (WWF), union established in 1902;
• Jim Healy, general secretary WWF 1937-1961;
Harry Jensen, Lord Mayor of Sydney 1957-1965;
‘Pointer’ families that give the Precinct its distinctive social character;
Colonial merchant class, represented by ownership of Bligh House (43 Lower Fort St) know also as ‘Clydebank’ by the Campbell family which Robert Crawford, Principal Clerk to Alexander Macleay lived in;
Later merchant class who invested in major warehouses (Towns and Parbury);
Prominent Sydney citizens of the mid nineteenth century such as John Fairfax of the Sydney Morning Herald who enjoyed the proximity to the town. (The relatively modest scale of the houses at Miller's Point, and the relative importance of its pre 1870 inhabitants reflects the economic circumstances and the aspirations of the citizens of the town of Sydney);
1880s property investors who built substantial rows of terrace houses of which 1-19 Lower Fort Street is the finest in Miller's Point, and the grandest surviving terrace in New South Wales;
• Publicans, as key civic figures, for example, the Armstrong family of the Palisade Hotel; the Irish community, as a major social group,
Significant architects and their work: H. Ginn & E. Blacket : Holy Trinity Church; W. L. Vernon : Post Office; A. Dawson : Observatory; J. Watts and M. Lewis : Fort Street School (also H. Robertson); M. Lewis : Richmond Villa, Kent Street (moved from Domain c.1975); J. Verge : 39 41 Lower Fort Street; G. McRae : 1910s workers' housing; V. Parkes : proposals c.1910 to Sydney Redevelopment Advisory Board for new hygienic tenaments between Argyle Place and Windmill Street; W. Wardell : Grafton Bond Store,
Members of the Sydney Harbour Trust Board: RRP Hickson, chairman Sydney Harbour Trust
Artists, and the discovery of the pictorial qualities of Australia including urban squalor, waterfront incident and the harbour bridge: Prout and Rae 1840s in Sydney Illustrated; S. Elyard 1860s; Lindsay family c.1900; W. Hardy Wilson c.1910;Cazneaux c.1920; Dorrit Black c.1930.
The Observatory has an association with an extensive array of historical figures, most of whom have helped shape its fabric. These include colonial governors, military officers and enginers, convicts, architects and astronomers (Kerr 1991: 39).
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
SHR Criteria c) [Aesthetic significance] | MillersPoint is of state significance for its landmark qualities as a terraced sandstone peninsula providing an eastern ‘wall’ to the inner harbour and supporting the fortress-like southern approaches to the Sydney Harbour Bridge; for its aesthetic distinctiveness as a walking-scale, low-rise, village-like harbourside district with its central ‘green’ in Argyle Place, and its vistas and glimpses of the harbour along its streets and from escarpments, as well as for the technical innovations evident in the remoulding of the natural peninsular landform from the hand-picked Argyle Cut to the ongoing levelling and terracing of the western slopes..
The area contains numerous original and characterful views to and from the harbour that are formed by a combination of dramatic topography and long physical evolution. It is the extent, the expansiveness, the change of view of individual buildings as the viewer moves around the water that gives the place distinction and significance.
The area is distinctive in that the escarpment edge is sharply defined by rock faces, concrete walls and vertical barriers that separate it from the waterfront.
The area is distinctive in that it has no single character but is made up of contrasts; juxtapositions of often disparate elements such as the stark edge of cliff or wall against the softer park or walkway; redefined and rebuilt wharf structures with new gently uses that belie their history, stylistically defined period of housing development that follows a well established pattern of small lot housing now contrasted with modern apartment/warehouse style dwellings.
The variety, complexity and scale of views from the wharfs, observatory hill, from roadways, edges of escarpments and walls are significant in defining the character of the area. The area is significant as aside from the southern edge of the precinct it is not overpowered by city scale development. The area contains numerous streets and lanes of historical and aesthetic interest. The area contains numerous features such as steps, fences, rock cuttings of historical and aesthetic interest.
The value of the area is further enhanced by its separation from the Rocks precinct which is predominantly commercial in use with Millers Point retaining its residential character, in particular worker housing. This is a rare continuing use. The character of the area is almost defined on a street by street basis rather than a broad precinct basis. With very few exceptions every element of the precinct contributes to the whole in a significant way.
The area has long been a source of creative inspiration, being imaginatively depicted by painters such as Joseph Fowles, James Taylor, Frederick Gosling, Eugene Delessert, Rebecca Hall, Samuel Elyard and John Rae in the mid-19th century and Lionel Lindsay, Sydney Long and Harold Greenhill in the early to mid-20th century; by photographers such as Johann Degotardi and Bernard Holtermann in the 1870s, John Harvey and Melvin Vaniman in the early 20th century, and Harold Cazneaux and Sam Hood in the 1930s; as well as being cartographically rendered by colonial map makers such as Dawes (1788), Lesueur (1802), Meehan (1807) and Harper (1823) and later engravers such as those working for Gibbs Shallard (1878) and the Illustrated Sydney News (1888).
The area has a range of architectural styles that are both intact and excellent examples of their type, many of which are rare surviving shops and dwellings, with specific importance attributed to the Observatory, Fort Street School, Holy Trinity Church and Millers Point Post Office, as well as colonial housing, hotels, and commercial amenities. It demonstrates characteristic dramatic harbourside topography that has been modified for human purposes, and is regarded as a complete and cohesive area due to contributory materials, form and scale, with clear definition brought about through the location of the Sydney Harbour Bridge and Bradfield Highway, Walsh Bay and Darling Harbour.
It demonstrates technical and creative excellence of the period 1820 to 1930, including, warehousing, civic facilities and landscaping, the observatory, hotels, public housing and its support facilities, colonial housing and the Garrison Church buildings. This is contrasted with modern apartment/warehouse style dwellings and the redeveloped wharves.
The National Trust Centre (and associated buildings) are significant for their sequential development initially as a Military Hospital and then as an educational institution throughout the last half of the nineteenth century. They have aesthetic significance at a State and local level.
The elevation of the Observatory site with its harbour and city views and vistas framed by the mature fig trees of the surrounding park, make it one of the most pleasant and spectacular locations.
• The Observatory picturesque Italianate character and stylistic interest of the observatory and residence building, together with the high level of competence of the masonry (both stone and brick) of all major structures on the site, combine to create a precinct of unusual quality. (Kerr 1991: 39).
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
SHR Criteria d) [Social significance] | Millers Point is of state significance for its potential to yield information from its archaeological resources not readily available elsewhere including oviform drains, early kerb and guttering, woodblock or other features that remain extant in Millers Point.
The changing domestic life of the residents has been documented in several excavations of residential sites;
The area contains examples of buildings demonstrating each stage and every major component in the history of the suburb, the only exception being for the period 1788-1820.
The building and archaeological fabric of the place has remained intact through community opposition to redevelopment, resulting in a large number of sites within the locale that remain comparatively or minimally undisturbed.
The physical evidence of the area’s history is complemented by the wealth of oral history contained within the existing resident population, which is a rare resource that allows a greater opportunity to understand the historic role of Millers Point and its social frameworks.
The Sydney Observatory continues a tradition of astronomical research that began with the first observatory on Dawes Point in 1788. The changing defences of Sydney are also evident in the areas archaeological resources, notably at the site of Fort Phillip. Underlying this diverse potential for researching changing human occupation is also the potential for the peninsular landform itself, constantly shaped and re-shaped by human agency, to yield information on the abilities of the people of NSW to continue to craft cultural landscapes of strong aesthetic appeal. The surviving structures, both above and below ground, are themselves physical documentary evidence of 195 years of changes of use, technical development and ways of living. As such they are a continuing resource for investigation and public interpretation. (Kerr 1991:39)
Millers Point layered fabric, both in terms of structures and archaeology, has had relatively little disturbance since intervention by the Sydney Harbour Trust and has the potential to provide valuable evidence about the place and its community.
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
SHR Criteria e) [Research potential] | Evidence from an archaeological excavation at Moore’s Wharf when it was moved showed continuing indigenous occupation at least until the 1830s and it is possible other such sites exist.
Millers Point is of state significance for its potential to yield information from its archaeological resources not readily available elsewhere including oviform drains, early kerb and guttering, woodblock or other features that remain extant in Millers Point.
The changing domestic life of the residents has been documented in several excavations of residential sites;
The area contains examples of buildings demonstrating each stage and every major component in the history of the suburb, the only exception being for the period 1788-1820.
The building and archaeological fabric of the place has remained intact through community opposition to redevelopment, resulting in a large number of sites within the locale that remain comparatively or minimally undisturbed.
The physical evidence of the area’s history is complemented by the wealth of oral history contained within the existing resident population, which is a rare resource that allows a greater opportunity to understand the historic role of Millers Point and its social frameworks.
The Sydney Observatory continues a tradition of astronomical research that began with the first observatory on Dawes Point in 1788. The changing defences of Sydney are also evident in the areas archaeological resources, notably at the site of Fort Phillip. Underlying this diverse potential for researching changing human occupation is also the potential for the peninsular landform itself, constantly shaped and re-shaped by human agency, to yield information on the abilities of the people of NSW to continue to craft cultural landscapes of strong aesthetic appeal. The surviving structures, both above and below ground, are themselves physical documentary evidence of 195 years of changes of use, technical development and ways of living. As such they are a continuing resource for investigation and public interpretation. (Kerr 1991:39)
Millers Point and Walsh Bay layered fabric, both in terms of structures and archaeology, has had relatively little disturbance since intervention by the Sydney Harbour Trust and has the potential to provide valuable evidence about the place and its community.
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
SHR Criteria f) [Rarity] | Natural Heritage
Millers Point is an important area in the Sydney City LGA, and its prominence is emphasised by its strong topography, particularly as viewed from the Harbour.
Non indigenous
Millers Point is of state significance as a rare, if not the only, example of a maritime harbourside precinct that contains evidence of over 200 years of human settlement and activity that spans all historical phases in Australia since 1788. While there are other historical maritime precincts in Australia that might show a comparable mix of historical and contemporary values, none are as old or so intimately associated with the spectrum of historical, social, aesthetic, technological and research values that have shaped Australian society since 1788.
The area is one of a few unique sites in Australia because of a strong sense of cohesion facilitated by a range of complementary architectural, structural, physical and social elements. The maintenance of both original fabric in a more or less intact state, and the successive generations of Millers Point residents, allows for a degree of rarity and authenticity.
Millers Point has significant structures, and has in close proximity a range of shipping and wharf structures that are believed to be of international significance.
The area has a range of early buildings with specific functions that are rare within the Australian context, such as the Lord Nelson Hotel and the Observatory.
Its unity, authenticity of fabric and community, and complexity of significant activities and events make it a significant historic urban place in Australia.
The National Trust Centre (and associated buildings) are rare surviving example of modifications to an Old Colonial Georgian hospital building for use as a mid-nineteenth century school.
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
SHR Criteria g) [Representativeness] | Millers Pont is of state significance for its ability to demonstrate the principle characteristics of 19th and 20th century Australian maritime harbourside or dockland precincts, such as a close proximity between workplace and work residence; the development of new methods for moving produce and passengers between land and water; interaction between natural elements such as water and wind and cultural elements such as wharves, boatyards and warehouses; and the constant remaking of the shoreline and its hinterland in response to changing economic, social, political and environmental factors in order for it to remain viable as a living, working place.
The area typifies the nineteenth and twentieth century residential and maritime environments through the retention of a range of architectural styles and buildings. It contains good examples of both domestic and commercial Australian building forms, including a clearly discernible staged evolution of housing progression of housing from the Ark on Kent Street to early twentieth century Australian Edwardian terrace houses.
The social and public nature of neighbourhood hotels and corner shops can be identified as typical of nineteenth century social spaces. The retention of such structures are demonstrative of the earlier ‘everyday’ environment of Millers Point, with the combination of formerly commonplace buildings within a distinct space making the representative nature of Millers Point of extremely high standard.
The National Trust Centre (and associated buildings) are representative as fine examples of the Victorian Regency and Victorian Free Classical styles as used in public school buildings in the mid-nineteenth century
Meets this criteria at a state level. |
| Integrity/Intactness: | Millers Point is a remnant of the government port of Sydney and is remarkable as a collection of buildings of high integrity, resulting in an important historic residential precinct in very good condition. The area retains a strong ability to demonstrate its significance. |
| Assessment criteria: | Items are assessed against the State Heritage Register (SHR) Criteria to determine the level of significance. Refer to the Listings below for the level of statutory protection. |